Film Criticism
Are You Not Entertained?
Gladiator and the politics of spectacle
by Lucas Ferreira · 2 min read
Nothing in Gladiator (2000) happened. Marcus Aurelius did not plan to restore the republic; Commodus did not murder him; no general named Maximus was enslaved and came back to kill an emperor in the Colosseum. Historians have been listing the errors for twenty-five years. It is a strange way to treat a film that gets the important thing right.
The important thing is that Commodus, in the film as in Cassius Dio, understands power as performance. The historical Commodus fought in the arena himself — hundreds of times, by Dio's count, against animals and against men whose weapons had been blunted. He renamed Rome after himself. He had the Senate cheer him as Hercules. The film's version, sulking in the imperial box, is tame by comparison.
The mob is the constitution
Scott's script, mostly through the senator Gracchus, keeps saying a thing that sounds like screenwriting and is actually Juvenal: Rome is the mob, the mob wants spectacle, and whoever gives the best spectacle governs. When Maximus turns to the crowd after the Carthage sequence and shouts Are you not entertained?, the film's argument arrives in one line. The arena is not a distraction from politics. It is politics, with the votes counted in noise.
This is why the climax works despite its absurdity. Commodus cannot simply have Maximus executed, because the crowd has chosen him; so he must beat him in the arena, in public, and he cannot. Power that depends on spectacle can be lost in spectacle. The film knows this the way Dio knew it: the real Commodus was strangled in his bath by a wrestler, on the eve of another appearance in the arena.
What the film refuses
Maximus is offered Rome and does not want it. This is the film's Augustan gesture — the refusal that legitimises — and the film is honest enough to make him die instead of rule. A general who wins the crowd and declines the throne is a fantasy; Rome's actual generals, from Sulla to Caesar to Septimius Severus, did not decline. But the fantasy tells you what the film thinks leadership is: not the taking of power but the ability to be trusted with it, proved by not wanting it.
Watch it again as a film about Commodus rather than Maximus. It becomes a study of a ruler who has confused applause for consent, and who discovers, too late, that the two are not the same currency.
About the author
Lucas FerreiraFilm and the ancient world. Thinks Gladiator is a political film and will defend it.
Essay
The Mask of Augustus
Augustus wrote his own obituary and had it carved in bronze. Read closely, it is less a record than a performance of restraint.
by Priya Raman · 2 min read
Translation & Commentary
How Long, Catiline?
The most famous opening in Latin prose is three questions in a row. A translation, and a note on why Cicero asks rather than tells.
by Theo Adeyemi · 2 min read
Essay
Antigone Says No
Creon is not a tyrant at the start of the play. He becomes one by refusing to be told he is wrong.
by Sofia Ricci · 2 min read